In this episode of The Media and Marketing Show, we sit down with Dr. Ron Irwin, senior lecturer at UCT’s Centre for Film and Media, branding expert, and author. During our conversation we unpacked the complex, multi-billion-rand world of counterfeit goods in South Africa.
We often think of counterfeits as cheap knock-offs sold at flea markets, but the reality is far more complicated: fakes now move through formal retail, challenge consumer trust, and force brands to rethink how they protect their IP in a market where the consumer may not be on their side.
In this episode, we covered:
Dr. Irwin explains how his teaching at UCT’s Centre for Film and Media connects brand management, media studies, and crisis communication. He also frames why counterfeits are not just a legal issue but a marketing and consumer-behaviour problem that brands can no longer ignore.
Looking back over three decades in South Africa, Dr. Irwin traces how the counterfeit economy grew from flea-market stalls into a multi-billion-rand industry that now reaches formal retail. He asks whether IP enforcement tools have actually brought brands closer to winning, or whether the war has simply changed shape.
Dr. Irwin distinguishes between buying counterfeits for survival and buying them as a form of resistance. In a country with soaring inequality, this raises a uncomfortable question for brands: is the counterfeit consumer a victim, a criminal, or a revolutionary—and what does that mean for IP protection?
He reflects on years of teaching branding and asks whether South African brands helped create their own counterfeit crisis by selling aspiration to consumers who could never legitimately afford it. The discussion explores whether brands are complicit in the problem when the majority of consumers live below the breadline.
The conversation moves from street corners into formal retail chains, where counterfeits can appear knowingly or unknowingly. Dr. Irwin examines whether the distinction between real and counterfeit commerce is collapsing, and what that means for consumer trust in brands.
He grew up in Buffalo, New York, USA, where counterfeiting is treated as organised crime, but in South Africa it is often a survival strategy. He explains why brands must recalibrate their messaging when consumers do not see counterfeiting as a crime and may even see it as a rational choice.
As a crisis communication expert, Dr. Irwin unpacks what brands get wrong when they discover their products are being counterfeited or when they are accused of copying an independent designer’s work. He outlines the right playbook and the one move that always backfires.
Dr. Irwin discusses how writing novels has given him a creative outlet beyond academic research and brand strategy. He reflects on how fiction exercises the same skills he uses in teaching and research: observation, narrative, and understanding human motivation.
Dr. Irwin introduces his forthcoming book, Nomos Logos: Counterfeits in South Africa, and explains its provocative title. The book argues that counterfeits are not just illegal copies but a competing system of law and logic—and he considers whether that ultimately terrifies brand owners or offers them a way forward.
Connect with Dr Ron Irwin:
Website: https://www.ronirwin.com/
LinkedIn: / ronaldirwin
Media & Marketing Show
About the Show
The Media and Marketing Show features in-depth conversations with media professionals, academics and industry leaders in communications, PR and marketing. In an ever-evolving media landscape, guests share their rich professional experience and explore how they navigate change.
Subscribe for more conversations with the people shaping media, communications and public debate.
A podcast on Radio 786
Watch pass episodes of the Media and Marketing Show: • Media & Marketing Show
Subscribe: / @radio7869
Hosted and produced: Hasanain Abdullah
Videography & Post-production: Aghmat Achmad
