Can Hadith Contradict the Qur’an? Authenticity & Understanding

In this continuation of our thought-provoking discussion, Halqa – Back to the Basics returns to an important question: Can the Qur’an be followed exclusively, without relying on Hadith?

In our previous discussion, we explored the authority of the Qur’an, the role of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and whether Hadith is an essential source of religious guidance alongside the Qur’an.

This time, we take the conversation further by examining the authenticity, collection and preservation of Hadith, and how Muslims should approach narrations that appear to conflict with the teachings and principles of the Qur’an.

Joining us once again are:

Dr Yusuf Noor – Medical doctor, author and researcher.

Dr Anwar Shaikh – Advocate of a Qur’an-centred approach to understanding Islam.

Sheikh Isma-eel Isaacs – Imam-Khatib at the Jumu’ah Mosque of Cape Town, attorney and educator in Arabic and Islamic studies.

This discussion aims to examine differing perspectives, engage with challenging questions and encourage a deeper understanding of the relationship between the Qur’an, Hadith and Sunnah.

Watch the full discussion and join the conversation.

The views and interpretations expressed by the guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Radio 786.