The Western Cape High Court has reserved judgment in the leave to appeal application of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign and five individuals who seek to challenge a Cape High Court order that restricts how they can protest against Cape Union Mart and its executive chairperson, Philip Krawitz.
The PSC argues that the sweeping order must be reined in. It says the order goes beyond what the court found, and it binds individuals for things others said. It notes that this matters for every protest movement in South Africa. The company has opposed the application and says the order is fair.
In September, the court barred the PSC from linking Cape Union Mart, its brands, and chairperson to the Israeli regime and its genocide in Gaza. It found that the respondents had failed to produce direct evidence in making the link. However, the PSC had based its protests and boycott campaign on Krawitz’s use of his networks to raise funds for the Israeli entity through his association with pro-Israeli organisations.
PSC coordinator Professor Usuf Chikte says their “counsel told the court that the order bars whole categories of future statements that we can make, and not just the words that the court found to be unlawful, which we’re going to contest.
The order also holds everybody responsible for what others said with no proof of what they said, or what each one of them said separately. So it’s a bit of a problem for us.”
Meanwhile, Cape Union Mart’s application to have the court order enforced while the appeal process runs will be heard by three judges. A date has yet to be set for this.
